The Doctors (Part 2)
(Timeline: 2005 to Present)

“You know, Doctor, I can't tell if you're a genius or just incredibly arrogant."
"Well, on a good day, I'm both.”
- Orient Express Conductor and The Twelfth Doctor

The Ninth Doctor
Played by Christopher Eccleston
2005 (Season 1)


    Christopher Eccleston had the unenviable task of being the face of the "New" Doctor Who series in 2005. While the show had many things going for it, including humor, thrills, action and a beautiful new companion, had Eccleston's take on The Doctor not been appealing to long time fans and new viewers, the show might have lasted only one season. But Christopher was not only successful, he was "fantastic".

     Eccleston's "Nine" was a different kind of Doctor from the old days. Gone were the Beatle haircuts and groovy colorful duds. No rock star hair like The Doctor in the 1996 movie, no mile-long multi-colored scarves, silly hats, question mark shirts or celery worn on the lapel. Instead, this Doctor was a man with a plain leather jacket, a bushel full of repressed guilt and goofy faces, and a Northern accent (ROSE: "If you are an alien, how comes you sound like you're from the North?" / DOCTOR: "Lots of planets have a North!"). Aided by a first-class cast featuring Billie Piper as young shop girl Rose Tyler, Camille Coduri as her mum Jackie, and Noel Clarke as Rose's boyfriend Mickey Jones, Eccleston made it feel like The Doctor had never been away.

     Unfortunately, Eccleston only stayed the one season. After only thirteen episodes, it felt like he was only getting started, yet he was done. As such, as good as he was, Eccleston had the fewest iconic moments of all the new Doctors, the kind of things that stick with viewers such as David Tennant's long-delayed emergence from the Tardis ("Miss me?") in "The Christmas Invasion" or Matt Smith's feast of fish fingers and custard in "The Eleventh Hour". The Eccleston season was a lot of fun, eminently rewatchable, but only had one true classic story, the two-parter "The Empty Child/The Doctor Dances", written by Steven Moffat. If Eccleston did have one iconic moment, it would have to be his ecstatic "Everybody lives, Rose! Just this once - everybody lives!" near the end of "The Doctor Dances". Also memorable were his final words to Rose in the last episode before regenerating into his next body: "You were fantastic, absolutely fantastic. And you know what? So was I!" And he was.

Pictured above: Billie Piper as Rose Tyler with The Doctor.

"I saw the fall of Troy. World War V. I pushed boxes at the Boston Tea Party. Now I’m going to die in a dungeon. In Cardiff!"

     Christopher Eccleston explained why he left the showin several different interviews over the years without revealing many details. Finally, in a 2018 interview with Radio Times, he gave a more expansive explanation: "My relationship with my three immediate superiors — the show runner [Russell T Davies, obvious - ed.], the producer and co-producer — broke down irreparably during the first block of filming and it never recovered. They lost trust in me, and I lost faith and trust and belief in them."

    Eccleston blamed some of the problems on himself, including not having confidence in his own ability to do comedy. He described himself as "out of my comfort zone" in the part. None of his anger or frustration was aimed at co-star Billie Piper, whom he described as "very brilliant" but "very, very nervous and very, very inexperienced". It's still not the most coherent explanation of his early departurebut it is probably all we will get. I have to disagree with Mr. Eccleston on his comic ability - in his one and only season on the show, he was often brilliantly funny.

Pictured above: Christopher Eccleston and Russell T Davies

     Ever the gentleman, producer Russell T Davies refused to get into a fight with Eccleston in the press, preferring to speak about him in glowing terms in SFX Magazine: "He will always be my Doctor... Chris is a magnificent actor and a magnificent man... and he was a magnificent Doctor as well. I think his comedy is funny - he plays it brilliantly. I think the darkness was off the scale with him - when the Doctor's angry, it's spectacular... It’s a magnificent, never-to-be forgotten Doctor, and it was an honour to work with an actor delivering a performance like that.”

DOCTOR: I'm going to save Rose Tyler from the middle of the Dalek fleet. And then I'm going to save the Earth, and then, just to finish off, I'm going to wipe every last stinking Dalek out of the sky!
DALEK: But you have no weapons, no defenses, no plan!
DOCTOR: Yeah. And doesn't that scare you to death!

     Around the same time as Eccleston gave his interview, he started showing up at fan conventions for the first time. In 2018 at the London Film and Comic-Con, he ran into Matt Smith, who had played the 11th Doctor for from 2010 to 2013. For Doctor Who fans, this was a historical occasion!

     If you are in The States like I am, the Eccleston episodes were hard to come by. BBC America sometimes ran episodes of the Modern Doctor Who series but only recently did they show the Christopher Eccleston - Billie Piper season, in a marathon leading up to the eleventh season of the modern series. Some streaming services have the episodes available, but your best bet may be to track down Season One on DVD or Blu-ray. 13 Episodes, some nice extras, fairly cheap, well worth the investment.

     Selected Films: Jude (1996 - with David Tennant); Gone in 60 Seconds (2000); The Others (2001); 28 Days Later (2002); G.I. Joe: Rise of the Cobra (2009); Thor: The Dark World (2013)

Television: Second Coming (2003 - created by Russell T Davies); Lennon Naked (2010 TV Movie - he played John Lennon with Naoko Mori of Torchwood playing Yoko Ono)

"Excuse me. Would you mind not farting while I'm trying to save the world?"

(Christopher Eccleston to David Tennant)

The Tenth Doctor
Played by David Tennant
2006 to 2009 (Seasons 2, 3, 4 and one year of Specials)
2013 ("Day of the Doctor")
Other: The Sarah Jane Adventures: "The Wedding of Sarah Jane" (2009)


     Christopher Eccleston played a huge part in making the new Doctor Who series popular, but David Tennant's take on The Doctor kicked it into high gear. While there are fans who do not like his hyperactive Doctor, many more believe that he was equal to or better than even the great Tom Baker.

     During David Tennant's tenure, The Doctor had three separate traveling companions: shop girl Rose Tyler, physician-in-training Martha Jones, and temp office worker Donna Noble, each of whom brought a different dynamic to the Doctor - Companion relationship, thanks to smart scripts and the superb performances of Billie Piper, Freema Agyeman and Catherine Tate respectively. Through it all, Tennant was brilliantly manic and hilariously funny, while also keeping much of Christopher Eccleston's dark moodiness.

"Whut?.... Whut?... WHUT??"

     Season Two, Tennant's first season, featured the ongoing love story between The Doctor and Rose, a tale destined to end sadly. Season Three centered on The Doctor and the love-struck Martha Jones saving the world several times. After the excellent Christmas episode "Voyage of the Damned" co-starring pop singer Kylie Minogue, Season Four, with The Doctor and Donna Noble, eventually grew into a celebration of Tennant's run as the Doctor, with companions Rose and Martha returning, as well as time-traveler Captain Jack Harkness (John Barrowman), Sarah Jane Smith (Elisabeth Slayden) and other various cast members of the spinoff series Torchwood and The Sarah Jane Adventures, all helping to fight the good fight with The Doctor. (Yes, that was one looong timey-wimey sentence!)

"No second chances. I'm that sort of a man."

    After Season Four, Tennant, sans the usual companions, performed in five specials from Christmas 2008 through New Years 2010. The first was one of the best: "The Next Doctor", a fun romp in the past featuring David Morrissey (later to be The Governor in "The Walking Dead") in which The Doctor essentially became a companion to a man who believed he was The Doctor. This was followed by the "Planet of the Dead" which featured actress Michelle Ryan as an almost companion (and judging from her performance in this special she would have made a great one), "The Waters of Mars", an excellent, creepy episode set on a space station on Mars, and the often fun but ultimately disappointing two-part "The End of Time", in which The Doctor finally runs out of luck and is forced to regenerate.

     In 2017, Tennant summed up what it was like to be The Doctor in an interview on The Andrew Marr Show:  “It’s part of the national conversation. It’s part of our cultural furniture. That’s a huge honour to be in the middle of, but it’s quite a responsibility… It changes your life… It’s an undertaking.”

Selected Films: Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire (2005); The Decoy Bride (2011)

Selected Television: Broadchurch (2011 - 17); The Escape Artist (2013); Gracepoint (2014 - American remake of Broadchurch Series 1); Jessica Jones (2015 - Netflix Web Series).

In 2016, Tennant replaced the late Alan Young as the voice of Scrooge McDuck in the children's show DuckTales.

"You want weapons? We're in a library! Books! The best weapons in the world!"

Pictured above: (1) Billie Piper as Rose Tyler with The Doctor (2) Freema Agyeman as Martha Jones with The Doctor and (3) Catherine Tate as Donna Noble with The Doctor.                                        

Like Father, Like Son (Hogwarts Edition): In the 2006 two-parter "Rise of the Cybermen / The Age of Steel", The Doctor battles against megalomaniac John Lumic, who is creating an army of Cybermen to take over the world (a parallel world, but a world just the same). A year before,  actor Roger Lloyd Pack, who played Lumic, turned up in Harry Potter and The Goblet of Fire as Hogwarts Ministry Official Barty Crouch, Sr. His son, Barty Crouch, Jr., was played by none other than "The Doctor" himself, David Tennant.

                                            THE TENTH DOCTOR REGENERATES
                                           (David Tennant to Matt Smith)

The Eleventh Doctor
Played by Matt Smith
2010 to 2013 (Seasons 5, 6 and 7)
"Day of the Doctor" (2013)
"Deep Breath" (2014 - cameo)
Other: The Sarah Jane Adventures: "Death of the Doctor" (2010)
"An Adventure in Space and Time" (2013)


     If Christopher Eccleston had the daunting task of being the first "new" Doctor since 1996, Matt Smith had the equally daunting task of being the Doctor who replaced David Tennant. Adding to the pressure, Smith would not be helped out by any popular characters from the first four seasons - no Rose, Martha, Donna or Captain Jack returning to aid the Doctor in his adventures. With the exception of River Song, a character who showed up in the Season Four's "Silence in the Library/Forest of the Dead", viewers would be seeing an all-new Doctor and all new companions. It was like "New Who Version 2.0".

DOCTOR (to the Daleks): You're going to fire me at a planet? That's your plan? I get fired at a planet and expected to fix it.
RORY: In fairness, that is slightly your M.O.

     Smith's version of The Doctor was goofy, funny, lovable, awkward, self-admittedly OCD, and great fun to watch. He believed bow ties were cool and could never pass a fez without trying it out on his head. He invented nicknames for his companions - Amy was "The Girl Who Waited", later companion Clara Oswald was "Soufflé Girl" and "The Impossible Girl". In "The Impossible Astronaut", he introduced his companions Amy, Rory and River song as "The Legs, The Nose and Mrs. Robinson", and in "The Day of The Doctor", he nicknames The Tenth Doctor and The War Doctor "Sand Shoes and Granddad."

"Has anybody ever told you that you're a bit weird?"
"They never actually stop."

     The Eleventh Doctor's mind worked so fast that his theories on matters often came halfway out of his mouth before they completely reversed themselves and vanished into thin air. He always seemed to want to do ten things at once, and the one thing that really irritated him was sitting around doing nothing. He was the most otherworldly doctor so far in the new series, one who didn't quite get social norms and customs. New show runner Steven Moffat called him "an elegant shambles."

"You're Scottish. Fry something."

     Matt Smith was not David Tennant, but he followed Tennant brilliantly, made the character of The Doctor his own, and became an extremely popular Doctor.

     The Matt Smith years were filled with new show runner Steven Moffat's typically "timey wimey" storylines threaded throughout nearly every episode. Where Russell T Davies would move his stories from A to B to C, Moffat often started his stories on F, jumped back to B, went forward to Q, back to C, and so on. There is no doubt that Moffat was a talented writer, and his best stuff could blow you away. However, he could also be as annoying as hell when all you really wanted was a decent story and he was attempting to show you how clever he was, something that sometimes marred his Sherlock series too. Through it all, however, Matt Smith shined in his role as The Eleventh Doctor, as did Karen Gillan as Amy Pond and Arthur Darvill as Rory Williams as his two main companions. By his final episodes, he was traveling with new companion Clara Oswald, played by Jenna Coleman. And even if everybody knew it was coming, his regeneration into Peter Capaldi was still a semi-shocker.   

Pictured above: Karen Gillan as Amy Pond, with The Doctor.

"I'm the Doctor. I work in a shop now. Here to help. Look, they gave me a badge with my name on in case I forget who I am. Very thoughtful, as that does happen."

     When Matt Smith announced he would be leaving the show in 2013, he praised the fans of the show effusively: "The fans of Doctor Who around the world are unlike any other; they dress up, shout louder, know more about the history of the show (and speculate more about the future of the show) in a way that I’ve never seen before... Thank you so very much for supporting my incarnation of the Time Lord..."

Selected Films: Terminator Genisys (2015); Patient Zero

TV: The Sally Lockhart Mysteries (2006 - 2007 - Matt Smith had his first television role in the first episode of this two-episode Billie Piper-led series; The Crown (2016 - Present). While Smith played young Prince Phillip in this Netflix drama, his former co-star and "companion" Jenna Coleman played young Queen Victoria in the BBC series Victoria.

"I'm being extremely clever up here and there's no one to stand around looking impressed! What's the point in having you all?"

Pictured above: Matt Smith and Billie Piper in episode one of "The Sally Lockhart Mysteries"                                

                                       THE ELEVENTH DOCTOR REGENERATES
                                         (Matt Smith to Peter Capaldi)

The Twelfth Doctor
Played by Peter Capaldi
2014 to 2017 (Season 8, 9, 10 and Christmas Special "Twice in a Lifetime")
(2013)"Day of the Doctor" (extremely short cameo, eyes only)
Other: Class: "For Tonight We Might Die" (2017)

"Shut up!"

     Clara Oswald witnessed what must have been the quickest and most shocking regeneration yet. In one split second, the youngest looking Doctor of the new series, the Doctor she "fancied", became the oldest looking one. The Twelfth Doctor, played by Peter Capaldi, was almost the polar opposite of Matt Smith's. The Eleventh Doctor had nothing but hope for humanity; The Twelfth barely tolerated humans. Eleven showed endless affection for his companions; Twelve looked at the beautiful Clara Oswald and saw nothing but a round head and overly large eyes ("Stop that with the eyes! How do you do that anyway? It's like they inflate!"), and he cringed whenever she attempted to hug him. Eleven enjoyed talking to humans he didn't even know; Twelve deleted people from his brain as soon as they were no longer useful to him.

PSI: I still don't understand why you're in charge.
DOCTOR: Basically, it's the eyebrows.

     Although Steven Moffat was still running the show and contributing scripts, the first two Capaldi years had more pure stand-alone stories, or simple two-parters, with fewer wibbly-wobbly, timey-wimey tales. Jenna Coleman's Clara fitted in with The Twelfth Doctor better than with The Eleventh (my opinion - many other fans see it the other way), as, instead of The Doctor trying to figure her out (see our "Companions" page for more explanation on the mystery that was Clara "Oswin" Oswald), it was she who attempted to get to the heart (or two hearts) of The Doctor and help him integrate more with humanity.

DOCTOR: Oh, do you still have the Presidential Aircraft?
CLARA: I thought you didn't like being President of the World.

DOCTOR: No, but I like poncing about in a big plane.

    When Clara's time with The Doctor was up, he spent many years with his wife River Song, returning to Earth after her death. After some undetermined time, he settled down as a professor at St. Luke's University, where he met Bill Potts, a cafeteria worker at the school who nevertheless attended his lectures. Impressed with her curiosity and positive attitude, he took Bill under his wing and let her travel with him in the Tardis.   

     Humor has always been one of the show's strongest points, and Capaldi's Doctor was more serious than the previous three Doctors of the new series. Yet, he could be very funny. Capaldi's version of The Doctor - cranky, easily annoyed, dismissive, sarcastic - had inherent humor in it that often played out when you least expect it. (The Woody Allen-ish "on a good day, I'm both" line listed at the top of this page is a Twelfth Doctor classic). Still, If your favorite Doctor was the lovably goofy Matt Smith, Peter Capaldi's Doctor could take some time to warm up to.

     After three seasons, The Twelfth Doctor bid his own self goodbye, in the two-part "World and Time Enough" / "The Doctor Falls" and the year-ending 2018 Christmas special "Twice Upon a Time". Taken separately, each episode had it's share of flaws, but when watched back to back to back, they made for a rather epic goodbye to Capaldi and his version of The Doctor.

DOCTOR: This is Clara, not my assistant. She's, er, some other word.
CLARA: I'm his carer.
DOCTOR: Yeah, my carer. She cares so I don't have to.

     Peter Capaldi, who grew up loving the original series, thought he had achieved his life long dream of being on Doctor Who when he was cast in the fourth season episode "The Fires of Pompeii", never dreaming that only a few years later, he would be The Doctor". Still, after three seasons, Capaldi decided to leave the show. "I feel sad," he said in an interview with BBC Radio. "I love Doctor Who, it's a fantastic program to work on. It's been a huge pleasure to work with a family. I can't praise the people I've worked with more highly, but I've always been somebody that did a lot of different things. But I've never done one job for three years. This is the first time I've done this, and I feel it's sort of time for me to move on to different challenges."

Selected Films: Lair of the White Worm, Dangerous Liaisons (both 1988); In The Loop (2009 - film spinoff of the TV series The Thick of It, also starring Capaldi); World War Z (2013)

Selected Television: John and Yoko: A Love Story (1985 - played George Harrison); The Thick of It (2005 - 2012); Torchwood: Children of Earth (2009).

"So who's in charge now?  I need to know who to ignore."

Pictured above: (1) Jenna Coleman as Clara Oswald with The Doctor and (2) Pearl Mackie as Bill Potts with The Doctor.

The Little Gray Cells and The Big Blue Box: From 1989 to 2014, actor David Suchet starred on television as Agatha Christie's famous fictional detective Hercule Poirot. Peter Capaldi had been working steadily since 1981, appearing in many movies and television shows, so it was almost inevitable that Capaldi would eventually wind up in an episode of Agatha Christie's Poirot. In 1991, he played a part-time clown and artist in the episode "Wasp's Nest". Many years later, Suchet would return the favor, appearing in the 2017 Doctor Who episode "Knock Knock" as a creepy landlord.

Who Doctor? Me Doctor! : A few years before taking over the role of The Doctor from Matt Smith, Peter Capaldi appeared in the zombie film World War Z. His character, a World Health Organization Doctor, wasn't given a name in the film.  In the ending credits, he was listed as "WHO Doctor".

     As stated above, Peter Capaldi played the Roman Lobus Caecilius in the fourth season episode "The Fires of Pompeii" (see our Amy Pond/Rory Williams notes in the Companions section for more interesting trivia on this particular episode). Before becoming the Twelfth Doctor, however, Capaldi played mid-level government man John Frobisher (pictured left) in the 2009 five-part Torchwood:  Children of Earth. While the Doctor Who episode "The Girl Who Died" answered the question "Why did The Twelfth Doctor have the same face as Lobus?", we still wonder why Frobisher and The Doctor also look so much alike. My only real scientific guess is... they were both played by Peter Capaldi.

(Peter Capaldi to Jodie Whittaker)

The Thirteenth Doctor
Played by Jodie Whittaker
"Twice Upon a Time" (Christmas Special 2017)
and Season 11 (2018)

"Let's get a shift on!"

She’s working class, she’s northern, what can go wrong?” - Working Class/Northern Ninth Doctor Christopher Eccleston, approving of the new Doctor.

ALIEN: You're interfering with things you don't understand.
DOCTOR: Yeah, well, we all need a hobby.

    Such a major change in the show ("The Doctor is a woman!") had the fan base erupting in major discussion, much of it level-headed and polite debate, some of it useless squabbling and name-calling. Having watched all ten seasons so far, I have no problem with The Doctor regenerating into a woman. I found the tenth season disappointing (no really bad episodes, but, even counting the good two-part finale, no really amazing episodes either) so it was probably a good time to mix up the formula. As for The Doctor regenerating as a woman, yes, it may be a bit shocking, but only a little more shocking than Matt Smith's lovable Doctor regenerating into Peter Capaldi's grumpy Doctor.

     I also wonder if the support for or backlash against a female Doctor is related to how long fans have been watching Doctor Who.  That is - are the long-time fans of Classic Who whose first Doctor might have been William Hartnell, Jon Pertwee or Tom Baker more apt to be against a female Doctor than the fans who tuned into New Who and whose first Doctor may have been Christopher Eccleston or David Tennant or perhaps even Peter Capaldi? No idea, but it is an interesting hypothesis. 

"Laugh hard. Run fast. Be kind."

 - The Twelfth Doctor's advice to his immediate future self.

     A pal of mine who really likes Whittaker thinks that she is being held back by the powers that be. It is like she can be goofy, but not too goofy; she can be angry, but not too angry, and so on. I can see where he is coming from just comparing The 13th Doctor to her four predecessors.  The 9th Doctor had moments of sheer anger, calling human "stupid apes". In The 10th Doctor's first episode, he gave a villain one chance to leave, and then, when that didn't work, he killed said villain. The 11th Doctor, undoubtedly the goofiest and wackiest of the modern era, nevertheless showed how much anger was inside him in only his second episode, "The Beast Below". Jodie Whittaker's 13th Doctor has yet to have a similar moment. I suspect it is because so much is riding on this particular Doctor that they are almost afraid to let her loose.

     Whittaker has definite David Tennant / Matt Smith vibe in her characterization of The Doctor. I'd say more Smith than Tennant, but both are in there, along with a humanity that hearkens back to Peter Davison as The Fifth Doctor. Whittaker's Doctor has also either regained or always had knowledge of Venusian aikido, something her third incarnation had (Jon Pertwee).

"You've redecorated... I really like it!"

     As quoted in the Daily Mail not long after the announcement, Whittaker said she expected to hear from former Doctors. "I know Matt Smith, Chris Eccleston and obviously David Tennant. Oh! And let's throw in David Bradley! Four Doctors! So I'm hoping I get some calls of advice."



     I will not be commenting much on The Thirteenth Doctor until Whittaker finishes her first season as The Doctor.

"Why are you calling me 'madam'?"
"Because... you're a woman?"
"Am I?! Does it suit me?"
"Oh yeah! I remember now! Sorry - half an hour ago I was a white-haired Scotsman."

Selected Films: Attack the Block (2011)

Selected Television: Broadchurch, Series 1 - 3 (2011-17); "The Entire History of You" Black Mirror, Episode 3 (2011)

It All Comes Out in the Walsh: Actor, presenter, and game show host Bradley Walsh will play Graham O'Brien, one of the 12th Doctor's new companions.  A versatile performer, Walsh is probably best known in his home country for hosting game shows and for his eight-season stint as Detective Sergeant Ronnie Brooks on Law and Order: UK, created by Dick Wolf.

     Wolf commissioned Chris Chibnall to find American Law and Order episodes that could be reconfigured and converted to stories that would work under British law. The show became a hit in Britain, and for several seasons, Walsh shared screen time with Doctor Who alumnus Freema Agyeman, who played junior prosecutor Alesha Phillips. Walsh stayed on the show for eight seasons, outlasting all the other main actors. Among his other work, Walsh played Danny Baldwin in Coronation Street from 2004 to 2006, and the shape-shifting alien in a 2008 episode of The Sarah Jane Adventures.

     Even with a shorted ten-episode season and sharing screen time with two other companions, The Doctor and whoever they were battling, Walsh made his mark on Doctor Who, with his character Graham O'Brien becoming, in my opinion, one of the greatest modern companions.

My Ranking Of All The Doctors

I've listed every Doctor to date in order of my own preference. Need to say though - I love them all.

1. David Tennant (10th Doctor)
I loved the Eccleston series, but David Tennant's run as The Doctor blew me away.

2. Jon Pertwee (3rd Doctor)
A superb Doctor who defined his era with a flourish!

3. Peter Capaldi (12th Doctor)
Not the most user-friendly Doctor, at least not at first. His three-year character growth, helped by his companions, hooked me.

4. Tom Baker (4th Doctor)
If I watched the original series before the new series, Tom Baker would undoubtedly be my favorite Doctorthough seven seasons was possibly a season too many.

5. Matt Smith (11th Doctor)
There is usually a short period when a new Doctor arrives in which you have to adjust. It took about 10 minutes before I adjusted to Matt Smith.

6. Sylvester McCoy (7th Doctor)
A surprise for me - I didn't expect him to rank so high. Maybe the only Doctor whom I added an extra point or for his companion. But The Seventh Doctor is a much better Doctor with Ace than without.

7. Christopher Eccleston (9th Doctor)
An excellent Doctor. If only he had stayed one more season.

8. William Hartnell (1st Doctor)
Simply wonderful! He paved the way for everybody who followed!

9. Colin Baker (6th Doctor)
His reign as The Doctor was problematic for many, but he had a Roger Moore quality to him that really worked. It took a friend of mine to really make me understand where this Doctor is coming from.

10 Jodie Whittaker (13th Doctor)
Based on her first season as The Doctor, I rank her somewhere in the middle. I like her, but she hasn't wowed me. More personality than Peter Davison, less than Colin Baker.

11. Peter Davison (5th Doctor)
Not much of a personality, but his three years were very entertaining overall with some wonderful stories.

12. Paul McGann (8th Doctor)
Great in the 1996 movie and superb in the 2013 mini-episode "Night of the Doctor". Had he done more, I would have ranked him above Peter Davison and Colin Baker.

13. Patrick Troughton (2nd Doctor)
I couldn't get much of a handle on him - too many missing episodes. But he was fun.

14. John Hurt (The War Doctor) (unnumbered)
Not much to say except he was John Hurt, and that can't be a bad thing. I can't rank him any higher, though, because he was only in one episode.

Next: The Modern Companions and Fellow Time Travelers

Go Back: The Classic Companions (1963-1989)

Doctor Who Main Page

The Secret Vortex

"Wait. You're going to go back in time. How do you do that?"
"Extremely well."
- Mason Bennett and The Twelfth Doctor